CPAP alternatives for sleep apnoea: what are your options?

CPAP alternatives for sleep apnoea: what are your options?

Continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) is the first-line treatment for moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnoea, and used every night it works very well. The difficulty is that a substantial minority of people cannot get on with it. The mask leaks, the pressure feels wrong, the nose blocks or dries out, or the whole arrangement simply feels impossible to sleep in. Many people give up within the first few weeks.

If you are looking for CPAP alternatives, you are in good company, and CPAP intolerance is a recognised clinical problem rather than a personal failing. At our Harley Street clinic in Central London, we regularly see patients who have tried CPAP in good faith and are now searching for sleep apnoea treatment without CPAP. The first step is to work out why the machine is not working for you, because the cause often determines the solution.

Some people only need a different mask or a treated nose to carry on with CPAP comfortably. Others are better served by an oral device, positional therapy, weight management or surgery, depending on the severity of their apnoea and the shape of their airway.

Struggling with CPAP is common and it is not the end of the road. An assessment can find the alternative that fits.

Why some people struggle with CPAP, and what to try first

Most CPAP problems fall into a handful of categories, and most have a practical fix. It is worth working through them before concluding that CPAP has failed, because the machine itself is rarely the real problem. The common difficulties are:

  • Mask problems: the wrong size or style causes leaks, pressure marks, sore skin and air escaping around the eyes.

  • Pressure intolerance: the air can feel forceful, make it hard to breathe out, or leave you bloated from swallowed air.

  • A dry or blocked nose: dryness, nosebleeds and congestion are among the commonest reasons people stop.

  • Claustrophobia and anxiety: wearing a mask can feel confining, particularly in the first weeks.

  • Practical barriers: noise, travel, a restless partner or the sheer inconvenience of the equipment.

The first fixes are simple. A mask refit is often the most valuable, since nasal pillow, nasal and full-face masks suit different faces and breathing patterns. A heated humidifier and heated tube reduce dryness, a ramp setting lets the pressure build gradually as you fall asleep, and many modern machines relieve pressure as you breathe out or adjust automatically to your needs. For anxiety, wearing the mask for short periods while awake, perhaps while watching television, helps many people become accustomed to it. Your CPAP provider should be able to help with each of these, and our CPAP service can review your set-up if you are not getting the support you need.

The nose matters: how blockage affects CPAP and what can be done

CPAP delivers air through the nose, or the nose and mouth, and a blocked nasal airway makes the whole system harder to tolerate. When the nose is obstructed, higher pressures are often needed to push air through, and many people respond by breathing through the mouth. That dries the throat, causes air leaks and wakes you at night, and the mask then gets blamed for what is really a nasal problem.

Common causes include a deviated septum, enlarged turbinates, chronic rhinitis, nasal polyps and collapse of the nasal valve. Treatment starts with the basics: a steroid nasal spray, saline rinses and treating any underlying allergy. If your nose stays blocked despite these, our article on why a nose can stay blocked despite antihistamines explains the other causes worth investigating. Where needed, an examination with a fine camera passed through the nose (fibreoptic nasendoscopy) shows the structure of the airway, and our rhinology service can assess and treat what it finds.

Where a structural problem is found, procedures such as septoplasty or turbinate reduction can open the airway. Nasal surgery rarely cures moderate to severe sleep apnoea on its own, but it can make CPAP far easier to use and sometimes lowers the pressure needed. For some people, fixing the nose is the single change that turns CPAP from impossible to manageable.

CPAP alternatives for sleep apnoea: the main options

The alternatives to CPAP differ widely in how effective they are and in who they suit. CPAP remains the most reliable treatment for moderate to severe disease, so any alternative should be chosen deliberately and its effect checked rather than assumed.

Mandibular advancement devices

A mandibular advancement device (MAD) is a custom-made oral appliance, similar to a sports mouthguard, that holds the lower jaw slightly forward during sleep. This widens the airway behind the tongue and reduces collapse. MADs work best in mild to moderate sleep apnoea and in people who snore, and they are a reasonable option for some people with more severe disease who cannot use CPAP. Side effects include jaw soreness, excess salivation and, over time, small changes in the bite, so a dental assessment is needed first.

Positional therapy

In some people, breathing pauses occur mainly when lying on the back, and a sleep study shows whether this applies to you. If it does, staying off your back can substantially reduce the number of events. Options include a small vibrating device worn on the chest or neck that prompts you to turn over, or a positional pillow or belt. It is not suitable for people whose apnoea persists in every position, and long-term use depends on how well you tolerate the device.

Weight and lifestyle measures

Excess weight narrows the airway, and losing weight can lower the severity of sleep apnoea, sometimes substantially. Cutting out alcohol in the evening, avoiding sedatives where possible, stopping smoking and keeping a regular sleep routine all help as well. These measures are valuable for everyone, but on their own they rarely control moderate to severe apnoea, so they are best seen as support for other treatment rather than a replacement for it. A medically supervised weight management plan can make the results more durable.

Surgery

Surgery aims to treat the specific place where your airway collapses. Depending on the findings, this may involve the nose, the tonsils, the soft palate or the base of the tongue. Outcomes depend heavily on choosing the right patient and the right procedure, which is why a detailed assessment always comes first. Our article on CPAP versus surgery for sleep apnoea covers how the two approaches compare.

If CPAP is not working for you, we offer assessment at Hillser Clinic to find the option that fits. Our obstructive sleep apnoea service brings together sleep studies, airway examination and treatment planning.

How the right option is chosen

The choice rests on a few facts: how severe your sleep apnoea is, how your airway behaves during sleep, your general health and what you are realistically willing to use night after night. Severity is established with a sleep study, which measures breathing pauses, oxygen levels and sleep position. Our article on what happens during a sleep study explains what to expect, and a previous study can be uploaded for specialist review so that it is not repeated unnecessarily.

Where the site of airway collapse matters, particularly if surgery is being considered, drug-induced sleep endoscopy (DISE) lets us watch the airway in action while you are in a light, medically induced sleep. Our guide to DISE and why it matters describes the procedure in detail. The result guides whether surgery, an oral device or a different approach is most likely to work. As a general guide:

  • Mild to moderate apnoea with good dental health: a mandibular advancement device is often worth considering.

  • Apnoea mainly when lying on the back: positional therapy may be effective.

  • A blocked nose behind failed CPAP: treating the nose may be enough to make CPAP workable.

  • A clearly identified site of collapse, or enlarged tonsils: surgery may offer a lasting solution.

  • Significant excess weight: weight management supports every other option.

Why untreated sleep apnoea should not simply be left

Obstructive sleep apnoea is more than loud snoring and tiredness. Repeated breathing pauses fragment your sleep and put the heart and circulation under strain, and untreated disease is associated with high blood pressure, atrial fibrillation, heart disease, stroke and type 2 diabetes.

For these reasons, giving up on CPAP without a plan is the one choice we would advise against. Please speak to your clinician before stopping CPAP, and keep using it as far as you can while alternatives are arranged, since even partial use is better than none. Our overview of sleep apnoea symptoms, diagnosis and treatment sets out how the condition is assessed, and a consultation can establish which alternative gives you effective treatment you can sustain.

Frequently asked questions about CPAP alternatives

Is there anything as good as CPAP?

For moderate to severe sleep apnoea, CPAP remains the most reliable treatment for controlling breathing pauses. However, the best treatment is the one you can actually use, and for the right patient an oral device or surgery can be effective. A repeat sleep study after starting an alternative confirms whether it is working.

Can surgery replace CPAP?

In carefully selected patients, yes. Surgery works when a specific, treatable site of collapse is identified, which is why assessment and often DISE come first. Some people still need CPAP at a lower pressure after surgery, or use it more comfortably once the nose has been treated.

What is a mandibular advancement device?

It is a custom-made dental appliance worn at night that moves the lower jaw slightly forward to keep the airway open. It is most effective in mild to moderate sleep apnoea and for some people who cannot tolerate CPAP. A dentist with sleep experience fits it, and follow-up checks the bite and the effect on your apnoea.

How do I know if my mask is wrong?

Warning signs include air leaking around the edges, red marks or sores on the skin, a dry mouth and waking with the mask off. Mask sizes and styles vary considerably, so a refit with your CPAP provider is often worthwhile before you give up. Data downloaded from the machine can also show how much leak is occurring.

Can I just stop using CPAP?

We would advise against stopping without a plan, because untreated sleep apnoea carries real risks for your heart, blood pressure and safety while driving. Speak to your clinician first, keep using CPAP as far as you can in the meantime, and arrange an assessment so that an effective alternative is ready.

Do I need a new sleep study before seeing a specialist in London?

Not always. If you have a recent sleep study or CPAP data, you can upload it before your appointment at our London clinic, and we will tell you whether it is sufficient. A new study is recommended when the previous one is out of date or does not answer the questions needed to choose a treatment.

Book a sleep apnoea consultation at Hillser Clinic

We offer expert evaluation of CPAP alternatives at Hillser Clinic, with a specialist ENT approach that examines the nose, airway and sleep study results together. To arrange a consultation, please contact our team.

Ms Maria Pulido

Ms Maria Pulido BSc (Hons), MD (ORL-HNS), DOHNS, EBFPS is a leading ENT Consultant, Rhinologist and Facial Plastic Surgeon at Hillser Clinic, specialising in the diagnosis and treatment of snoring, obstructive sleep apnoea and nasal conditions. She has trained at world-renowned institutions including Stanford University and Imperial College London, and is a member of ENT UK, the British Rhinology Society, the European Academy of Facial Plastic Surgery and the American Rhinologic Society.

Next
Next

Functional vs Cosmetic Rhinoplasty: Can You Fix Breathing and Appearance in One Operation?